Desalination Plant Under Construction at SEA Lab
The project, which will test ways to turn seawater into drinking water, has raised some environmental concerns.
A small desalination demonstration plant, funded by the West Basin Municipal Water District, is being built at the Los Angeles Conservation Corps' SEA Lab in Redondo Beach.
The plant will be testing ways of extracting water from the ocean in an environmentally friendly and cost-effective manner to convert it into drinking water with osmosis, a method commonly used for purifying bottled water.
The project, which is set to open late fall, is part of an initiative to reduce the amount of imported water in the South Bay from 66 percent to 33 percent by 2020.
"We will do this for two years, testing the wedge-wire screen, testing sub-ocean floor withdrawal, testing energy recovery, and if it all works out the way we want it to, we'll create a full-scale plant," said Ron Wildermuth, public and government affairs manager of the West Basin.
For now, the plant is simply a testing and learning facility where beach-goers can witness seawater being turned into drinking water.
"The reverse osmosis technology is what all the bottled water companies use, so people will realize that they're paying more for bottled water when their drinking water can go through the same process and cost 10 times less," said Alexis Tate, chief public information officer at the water district.
"We're going to have a video feed so visitors can see the wedge-wire intake pipe. We call it a wedge-cam," Wildermuth said, smiling. "I love it."
After the water is desalinized, the fresh water will be put back into the ocean with the brine, or concentrated salty leftovers.
"When you take saltwater and make fresh water, the salt from the original water becomes more salty," Wildermuth said. "We've done studies, and we think we know the right level of salt that we can send back to the ocean and not hurt the plants or animals."
The project does come with environmental concerns.
"[Environmentalists] are all watching," Wildermuth said. "They weren't opposed to our demo plant because they wanted to see what would happen. The water industry doesn't have the best environmental record. Owen's Valley and Hetch Hetchy are good examples of how it's gone wrong, so why should they trust us? They want to make sure we do it right, and there's nothing wrong with that."
One concern is that the brine could harm ocean life once it's released back into the water.
"We take more ocean water than needed for the process, dilute what goes back to the ocean and put it in a pipe with holes on the sides, so the water diffuses rather than a concentrated dump in one area," Wildermuth said. "We're confident about this being safe."
Another concern is that the plant won't be "green" enough, and that it will cost a lot of money.
"We use low-energy membranes--reverse osmosis membranes--and that's state of the art for water purification," Wildermuth said. "It's what Australia is using because of their drought. We'll use high-efficiency pumps, and eventually, renewable energy. We're diversifying our water portfolio, and for the same cost."
The operation at the desalination demonstration plant needs to be observed carefully, said Joe Geever, Southern California coordinator of the SurfRider Foundation.
"We have concerns about energy consumption," Geever said. "We understand the plant is addressing our concerns about the mortality issues by testing methods of intake, but we're waiting to see tests before we take a position."
Geever and other environmentalists would argue that there are opportunities to expand recycling before jumping to desalination.
"We definitely support the recycling and conservation, but we've crunched the numbers and if we expanded wastewater recycling all over Southern California, there would be less energy demand and it would eliminate the discharge to the ocean," Geever said.
"We are simply remaining at non-position until we see the results," he said.
The desalination plant is part of the Water Reliability 2020 program, which aims to reduce Southern California's dependency on imported water through doubling recycling and conservation efforts, expanding education and utilizing desalination plants.
"We've exhausted the resources that we have," Tate said. "We can only conserve so much more, and we can only recycle for as many customers we get to come onboard with recycled water. We need another supply."
Joe Galliani
3:11 pm on Monday, April 19, 2010
Like Joe Geever, I am concerned about the amount of electricity these desalination plants use and their resulting carbon footprint. Water already accounts for 20% of our electric use in California as we use huge amounts of energy to bring water to Southern California from Northern California.
We're doing a great job of cutting back on wasteful water use here in L.A. County but we could be doing a lot better.
50%-70% of our water use in Southern California is for landscaping. We waste tons of good drinking water on ornamental lawns all across the South Bay. And cities like Redondo Beach and Torrance waste not just water but lots of tax dollars watering grass covered public medium strips that serve primarily as dog walking landscapes.
So I hope that in addition to the cool 'wedge-cam' this desal test will also feature the electric meter cam and a cost of energy (both in dollars and carbon) counter that the public can check in on as well.
Ron Wildermuth
3:07 pm on Wednesday, April 28, 2010
Thank you Redondo Beach Patch for focusing on West Basin’s Desalination program and our emphasis on protecting the environment. West Basin has been protecting the environment for decades. Our water recycling plant keeps 30 million gallons of sewer water and five tons of solids from the ocean each day, our school and conservation programs focus on environmental protection, and we teach water efficient landscaping classes to prevent runoff.
I’d like to clarify a couple of points made in the article. The environmental community, along with West Basin, is rightfully concerned with energy needed to desalinate ocean-water. West Basin will be testing and studying energy recapture at the Demonstration project in Redondo Beach to capture and reuse it in the process. Another issue mentioned is brine discharge. West Basin will also study concentrated brine and dilute it before putting it back in the ocean. Based on research we have done already, we anticipate there will be no negative effects. The study will be on display in a split aquarium at the Demonstration facility.
As you can see, West Basin is making every effort to be transparent, including the environmental community and the public throughout the process. After six years of operating a pilot desalination project in El Segundo, we believe ocean-water desalination can be done responsibly and invite you to visit our facility this fall. Visit www.westbasin.org for more about Water Reliability 2020.
kyle
4:41 am on Thursday, December 2, 2010
but what are the negetive affects to the sea life and allaof the ocean when you remove the salt the ocean will frez
Joseph Trimble
10:44 am on Wednesday, April 20, 2011
Check out PROtector Treatment Systems - http://www.protectorsystems.com - They've built a reverse osmosis water treatment system for developing regions that is powered by hand!
Fred Reardon
8:55 am on Sunday, December 18, 2011
I am confused by the whole "testing the waters" approach. It may just be "testing the political waters?" Desalination using osmosis is not new? It uses a lot of energy, produces very toxic brine and kills sea life. Please stop this archaic polluting approach and start collecting and treating storm water. Storm water reuse will decrease pollution to our ocean and we will not need to harm sea life.